A History Loves Company Original

When you think of Belle Isle, you picture the fountain, the aquarium, the conservatory, the bridges, the trails, and the skyline views.
But before Belle Isle became Detroit’s iconic public park…
Before Frederick Law Olmsted designed its sweeping green spaces…

Belle Isle was a place of homes.
Real homes.
Family estates.
Private residences built long before the island became a destination.

Hidden in the sands of Detroit’s past are the stories of the first people who lived on Belle Isle — settlers, farmers, lighthouse keepers, and early Detroit families who called the island home decades before the public ever stepped foot on it.

Today, in Homes of Michigan, we bring those forgotten Belle Isle homes back to life.

Before the Park: Belle Isle’s Earliest Settlers

The first documented residents of Belle Isle were French settlers in the 1700s, when Detroit was still a young fur-trade settlement.
At that time, Belle Isle was known by many names:

• Île aux Cochons (Hog Island)

• Pig Island

• Okahoe Island, referencing Native American cultural roots

Early farmers used the island to graze animals, plant crops, and build small homesteads.
These weren’t elaborate mansions — they were frontier structures built for survival in a developing territory.

But as Detroit grew, so did the interest in this remarkable island.

Belle Isle’s Private Homesteads and Farmhouses

By the early 1800s, Belle Isle saw a rise in permanent residents. Families built simple cabins and farmhouses along the shoreline, raising livestock and tending to gardens.
These were some of the first private residences ever built on Detroit-owned land.

Historic records reference homes owned by:

• French farming families

• American pioneers who settled after the War of 1812

• Local land stewards who maintained crops and protected the island

• Trappers and river pilots who worked the Detroit River

Most of these homes were constructed from timber cut on the island itself — functional, modest, and built with purpose.

Today, none of these homes stand.
But the land remembers.

The Lighthouse Keepers: Homes at the Island’s Edge

One of the most fascinating lost residences on Belle Isle belonged to the lighthouse keepers.

The original Belle Isle Lighthouse, built in the mid-1800s at the east end of the island, housed keepers and their families. They lived on the island year-round, tending the flame to protect ships navigating the Detroit River.

For decades, this lighthouse keeper’s cottage was one of the most isolated homes in Detroit.

Eventually, both the lighthouse and its residence were dismantled — replaced by the modern facility still standing today.

The Elegant Estates That Never Survived

In the mid-1800s, wealthy Detroit residents began to eye Belle Isle as a potential resort and residential destination.
Plans were drawn for:

• A hotel resort

• Summer estates

• Recreational villas

And a handful of private cottages and early estates were built along the shoreline — simple, elegant homes designed for warm-weather stays.

These structures existed only briefly before the City of Detroit purchased Belle Isle in 1879 and began transitioning it into a full public park.

When Frederick Law Olmsted drew up plans in the 1880s, all remaining private homes were demolished.

Belle Isle was to belong to everyone — and the last private homes disappeared into history.

Belle Isle Becomes the Park We Know Today

After the land purchase in 1879, Detroit officially began converting Belle Isle into a public park, erasing nearly all traces of its residential past.

From that moment on, Belle Isle became:

• A place of recreation

• A cultural landmark

• A symbol of Detroit’s identity

• And one of the most visited parks in the Midwest

What remains today are the stories of the homes — not the structures.

See the Full Story in Homes of Michigan

In today’s episode, we walk you through:

• The forgotten farmhouse era of Belle Isle

• Where families once lived, farmed, and built early homes

• The sites of lighthouse keeper residences

• Shoreline areas where private cottages once stood

• Rare surviving maps and archival references

• And how this island transitioned from settlement → private homesteads → the public park we know today

It’s Belle Isle like you’ve never seen it before.

📺 Watch Homes of Michigan — Belle Isle Before the Park:
https://youtube.com/@historylovescompany

Every home has a story… even the ones that no longer stand.

🏡 Explore More Michigan Historic Homes

Discover the places, estates, and neighborhoods that built our state:
👉 Homes of Michigan Collection